State of strong emotional excitement in the criminal code of Ukraine: content of the concept and features of its usage

№ 2, 2025

Authors: Oleksandr KOROLENKO

Issue: № 2, 2025

Doi: https://doi.org/10.37634/efp.2025.2.14

The paper defines the meaning of the concept of the state of strong emotional excitement. The Criminal Code of Ukraine uses the concept of the “state of strong emotional excitement” as a mandatory feature of the subjective side of criminal offenses provided for by articles 116 and 123, as a circumstance that excludes criminal liability for exceeding the limits of necessary defense (part 4 of article 36) and extreme necessity (part 3 of article 39) and also as a circumstance that mitigates punishment, in accordance with clause 7 of part 1 of article 66, but does not disclose its meaning, which leads to different law enforcement practices. It is erroneous to identify a state of severe mental excitement with physiological affect, stress and depression, since, according to modern scientific views, physiological affect meets the criteria of a mental disorder and is much closer to pathological affect than to normal emotional reactions. Stress is a protective reaction of the body to external stimuli, which is symptomatically manifested through emotional reactions of anger, fear, anxiety, etc. And depression is generally a disease that occurs due to various adversities and experienced stresses. To determine whether a person was in a state of severe mental distress at the time of committing a criminal offense, a psychological and psychiatric examination should be prescribed, and establishing the circumstances that led to the emergence of a state of severe mental distress is the competence of the court.

Keywords : state of strong emotional excitement, physiological affect, stress, depression

References:

1. Criminal Code of Ukraine: Law of Ukraine dated 05.04.2001 № 2341–III. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14/ed20010405 (in Ukrainian).

2. Bailov A.V. Criminal liability for encroachment on the life and health of a person committed in a state of strong emotional excitement: abstract dis. … PhD in legal sciences. Kharkiv, 2004. 20 p. (in Ukrainian).

3. Scientific and practical commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine / P.P. Andrushko, V.H. Honcharenko, Ye.V. Fesenko. Kyiv, 2008. 1428 p. (in Ukrainian).

4. Scientific and practical commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine / M.I. Melnyk, M.I. Khavroniuk. Kyiv, 2019. 1384 p. (in Ukrainian).

5. Scientific and practical commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine / I.M. Kopotun. Kyiv, 2020. 864 p. (in Ukrainian).

6. Tereshchuk A.D. Diagnostic criteria for affective states of personality. Current problems of teaching and educating people with special needs. 2015. №12 (14). pp. 225-235. (in Ukrainian).

7. Avramenko O.V. State of severe mental distress: criminal law and psychological aspects: abstract dis. … PhD in legal sciences: Lviv, 2008, 19 p. (in Ukrainian).

8. Buchkivska V.L. State of strong emotional excitement in legal science. Legal scientific electronic journal. 2023. № 3. pp. 373-377 (in Ukrainian).

9. Ozerskyi I. Legal and psychological construct "state of strong emotional distress". Scientific Bulletin of the Dnipro University of Internal Affairs. 2024. № 2. pp. 196-200. (in Ukrainian).

10. Resolution of the Lviv Court of Appeal dated February 11, 2021 (case No. 307/2389/18) URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/95767747 (in Ukrainian).

11. Verdict of the Tlumatsk District Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Region dated April 27, 2022 (case No. 353/73/122). URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/ 104100739 (in Ukrainian).